
Highlights for Metal Roofs vs Shingles
Choosing the right roofing materials for your home in Middle Tennessee isn’t always easy. From Franklin to Murfreesboro and Spring Hill, homeowners face a big decision when it comes to protecting their home’s roof. Are you drawn to the sleek style of metal roofing, or do you prefer the affordability of asphalt shingles? Both have unique benefits and understanding what works best for your home—whether it’s a roof replacement or a new roof—makes all the difference. This guide breaks it all down so you can confidently choose between metal roofs and shingles.
Table of Contents
Metal vs Shingle Roofing in Middle Tennessee
Your roof is more than just a structure—it’s your home’s first line of defense against the elements. Here in Middle Tennessee, where the weather brings everything from high winds and heavy snow to scorching heat and sudden storms, you need roofing materials that can handle it all. Whether you’re considering a roof replacement or deciding on roofing options for a new home, the choice between metal roofs and shingles will impact everything from energy bills to curb appeal. Let’s walk through the pros and cons of each so you can make the best choice for your home and budget.
Understanding the Basics
What Are Metal Roofs?
Metal roofs are precisely what they sound like—roofs made from durable materials like steel, aluminum, or even copper. They’re designed to last a long time, typically over 50 years, and they’re known for being extremely durable. Metal roofs are energy efficient because they reflect heat from the sun, which can help lower your cooling costs during Tennessee’s hot summers. They’re also recyclable, so if eco-friendliness is a priority for you, metal roofing is a solid choice.
However, some people worry about a few things, like whether metal roofs are noisy during rainstorms. Thanks to modern technology, insulation now helps keep things quieter. Another concern is that metal roofs can dent if hit by falling branches or hail, though high-quality materials minimize this risk.
What Are Shingles?
Shingles, especially asphalt shingles, are the classic choice for many homeowners in Tennessee. Asphalt shingle roofing is made from a mix of fiberglass and asphalt, and it comes in various styles, such as three-tab and architectural shingles. While cost-effective and versatile, it has drawbacks, including concerns about durability, longevity, and potential impact on insurance premiums due to vulnerability to extreme weather conditions. Roofing contractors often recommend shingles because they’re easy to install and come in many colors and textures, making them ideal for any home style.
Asphalt shingles include several types, like three-tab shingles, architectural asphalt shingles, and traditional asphalt shingles. While shingles don’t last as long as metal roofs, they’re still durable enough to handle areas prone to storms or strong winds. Plus, repairing or replacing shingles is more affordable than fixing metal roofing.
Metal Roofs vs Shingles: A Detailed Comparison
Durability and Lifespan
If you’re looking for a roof that will last decades, metal roofing is the way to go. Metal roofs are incredibly durable and can handle just about anything—severe weather, high winds, and even fire. They’re a great choice for Middle Tennessee homes that face extreme weather conditions like heavy snow or falling branches.
On the other hand, an asphalt shingle roof typically lasts 15 to 25 years. While they’re not as long-lasting as metal, asphalt shingles are a cheaper and simpler installation choice. However, they are more vulnerable to weather damage and may require more frequent repairs when damaged by strong winds or water. So, if you’re okay with the idea of maintenance over the years, shingles might suit your needs.
Energy Efficiency
When it comes to energy efficiency, metal roofs energy efficient stand out due to their ability to reflect solar heat, leading to significant savings on cooling costs. They can lower your cooling costs by up to 25%, which is a big deal during Tennessee’s hot summers! Asphalt shingles aren’t as energy efficient as metal, but choosing lighter-colored shingles or Energy Star-certified options can help reduce heat absorption.
Aesthetic Appeal
Your roof is a huge part of your home’s curb appeal, so it has to look good. Metal roofs offer sleek, modern styles, and some even mimic the look of traditional roofing materials like slate, clay tiles, or wood shakes. They’re especially popular in areas like Franklin and Spring Hill, where farmhouse-style homes are all the rage.
Shingles, however, are the go-to choice for many homeowners because they’re versatile and come in so many colors and styles. A shingle roof is easy to install and integrates well with other roof features like chimneys and skylights. Whether you prefer bold or neutral tones, traditional asphalt roofs give you plenty of options to match your home’s look.
Cost Considerations
Metal roofs have a higher initial cost, averaging $7,858 to $14,412 for installation. While that might seem steep, their longevity and low maintenance can save you money in the long run. Shingle roofs, on the other hand, cost between $4,200 and $8,500 on average, making them more affordable upfront. If you’re planning to sell your home soon or you’re on a tighter budget, shingle roofing might be the better option.
Safety and Weather Resistance
When it comes to safety and weather resistance, metal roofs truly shine. Designed to withstand the harshest conditions, metal roofing can handle everything from heavy snow and hail to high winds. In fact, metal roofs can endure winds up to 140 miles per hour, making them an excellent choice for homes in hurricane or tornado-prone areas.
One of the standout features of metal roofs is their non-combustible nature, which has earned them a Class A fire rating. This makes metal roofing an ideal option for homes in wildfire-prone regions. Additionally, metal roofs resist mold and mildew, a significant advantage for homeowners in humid climates.
Impact resistance is another area where metal roofs excel. Unlike traditional asphalt shingles, which can crack or break under the impact of hail or falling branches, metal roofs are built to withstand such impacts. Studies have shown that metal roofs are up to 30% more resistant to impact damage compared to traditional asphalt shingles.
While metal roofs come with a higher initial cost than traditional asphalt shingles, their long-term benefits can lead to significant savings. Metal roofs are energy efficient, reflecting heat and sunlight, which can lower cooling costs. They also increase home value and require less maintenance, saving homeowners money on roof maintenance and repairs.
If you’re considering a metal roof for your home, consulting with a professional roofing contractor is a wise move. Many contractors offer free roof inspections, helping you assess the condition of your current roof and identify any potential issues. This can guide you in choosing the best type of metal roof for your needs and budget.
By choosing metal roofing, you’re investing in a durable, long-lasting roofing material that offers superior safety and weather resistance. This makes it a smart choice for any homeowner.
Benefits of Shingle Roofing
Variety and Affordability
Many homeowners in Middle Tennessee choose asphalt roofing because it’s budget-friendly and offers lots of variety. Asphalt roofing provides sound protection, versatility in application on different roof types, recyclability, and cost-effectiveness. You can find architectural asphalt shingles that are more durable and stylish than traditional materials, giving you plenty of ways to customize your roof.
Ease of Installation and Repairs
Shingles are quick to install, which means less labor and lower costs. Roofing contractors can also easily repair damaged shingles, keeping your roof in great shape without breaking the bank.
Energy-Efficient Options
If energy efficiency is a priority, consider Energy Star-certified asphalt shingles. They’re affordable, reduce heat absorption, and can help lower your energy bills.
Advantages of Metal Roofing
Eco-Friendliness and Strength
Metal roofs are sustainable, made from recycled materials, and recyclable at the end of their lifespan. They’re also incredibly strong, with a fire rating that gives homeowners peace of mind. Metal roofs durable in nature, resist extreme weather conditions, and have a longer lifespan compared to asphalt shingles. While other roofing materials might struggle in areas prone to strong winds or water damage, metal roofing stands up to the challenge.
Insurance and Resale Benefits
Thanks to their durability, metal roofs can lower your homeowner’s insurance premiums, especially in states like Tennessee that experience severe weather. Their sleek, modern style also boosts home resale value, making them an excellent choice for long-term homeowners or home buyers looking for premium features.
Local Considerations for Middle Tennessee
Weather and Durability
Middle Tennessee’s unpredictable weather makes durability a key factor in roofing materials. While asphalt shingles can withstand typical weather, wood shingles, though historically relevant, have mainly been replaced by more durable and eco-friendly options like metal roofing. Metal roofs offer longevity and sustainability and are better suited for extreme conditions like high winds, hail, and heavy snow.
Working with Roofing Companies
Choosing the right roofing contractors is as crucial as choosing the right materials. Five Points Roofing has been helping homeowners in Franklin, Spring Hill, Murfreesboro, and beyond for years, offering expert installation and guidance for metal and shingle roofs.
Why Choose Five Points Roofing?
At Five Points Roofing, we know that every home is unique. Whether you’re considering traditional shingles or a modern metal roof, we’ll help you find the perfect fit for your budget, style, and needs. Our team specializes in roof replacement and installation, and we’re proud to be Middle Tennessee’s trusted name in the roofing industry.
Conclusion
When choosing a roof for your home, think about what matters most to you. A metal roof might be the best option if you want something durable and energy-efficient that will last for decades. If you’re looking for affordability and style variety, you can’t go wrong with asphalt shingles. No matter what you choose, Five Points Roofing is here to help. Call us today to schedule a free consultation and get started on your new roof!